Traditional vs. Smart Collars: Definitions and Examples.

A traditional collar is the basic accessory worn by dogs and cats to attach a leash and hold identification (tags, bells, labels) (1, 2). It's usually made from simple materials like nylon, leather, fabric, or metal, and comes in various designs (flat, martingale, with a buckle, or quick-release for cats). For example, a flat nylon collar with a metal buckle is typical for daily walks, while a breakaway safety collar for cats detaches if it gets caught (2).

In contrast, a smart collar is a technological device that integrates sensors and wireless connectivity (3). These collars can include GPS or radio for location, accelerometers for activity, heart rate monitors, thermometers, LED lights, microphones, and geofencing features (4, 5). Popular examples include the Fi Collar, Whistle, Tractive, and PetPace (for health), as well as brands like Invoxia or Halo, some of which are sponsored by experts like Cesar Millan (6, 7). In most cases, a smart collar requires a mobile app or a cloud platform to receive real-time data (8, 9).

Comparative Advantages and Disadvantages

Here’s a breakdown of key categories to evaluate each type of collar:

• Functionality: A traditional collar serves basic functions: it allows for a leash to be attached, carries identification (tags with owner information), and, for dogs, can aid in basic training commands (pulling on the leash) (1). Its main advantage is its simplicity—it works anywhere without needing power. On the other hand, a smart collar adds advanced features: GPS or Bluetooth localization, step or activity counting, geofences (alerting you if the pet leaves a defined area) (10, 11), and monitoring of vital signs (e.g., heart rate, respiration, sleep patterns) (12). This increases safety by making it easier to rescue a lost animal (6). However, this enhanced functionality comes with limitations: a smart collar depends on a battery (requiring periodic recharging) (13), network or GPS coverage, and the reliability of the app. Furthermore, generic goals (like a "10,000 steps a day" target in the Fi example) may not apply to all animals (14), so the data should be interpreted with veterinary guidance.

• Health and Safety: In preventive health, smart collars offer clear advantages. They can detect early anomalies (changes in activity, heart rate, or respiration) and notify the owner or a veterinarian (11, 15). For instance, a collar with heart rate sensors can alert you to irregularities in a dog with a heart condition before they worsen (16). Additionally, geolocation features reduce the risk of losing a pet: safe zones (geofences) alert you if your pet escapes (6, 7). In contrast, a traditional collar protects through ID: it makes it easier for someone to return a lost animal (1, 2), but it doesn't prevent the loss in the first place. A common drawback for both is that a poorly used collar can cause harm: constant pressure on the neck (especially in brachycephalic dogs or strong pullers) can injure the trachea and cervical vertebrae (17). For this reason, veterinarians often prefer harnesses for small or problematic dogs, though they acknowledge the value of a traditional collar for identification and training (1, 17). For cats, breakaway collars are advised to prevent strangulation, and the use of bells is debated: they are useful for protecting birds but can be potentially stressful for a cat's hearing (18, 19).

• Pet Comfort: Traditional collars are typically light and simple, so most animals tolerate them well if they are fitted correctly (1). A good collar should allow two fingers to slide between the neck and the collar (20). The materials (soft nylon, thin leather) are usually comfortable, although some animals resist them, and it’s best to get them used to it as puppies or kittens (2). Smart collars, on the other hand, contain electronic components that add weight and rigidity. Products like the Invoxia collar are somewhat bulky, so they are generally only recommended for medium to large dogs (21). However, some models (e.g., TKMars, Fi) are relatively compact and allow for some slack (7, 22). A benefit of modern smart collars is that they can be worn a bit loosely without losing accuracy (22), which reduces discomfort. For cats, any collar (traditional or smart) must be especially lightweight and safe. In general, technological devices add complexity that can be uncomfortable (batteries, electronics), while simple collars only add minimal weight.

• Ease of Use: The traditional collar wins on simplicity: it requires no setup, just fitting it on the animal. It doesn't need charging or a connection, and anyone can use it (just buckle and adjust the size). In contrast, a smart collar requires multiple steps: installing a mobile app, user registration, battery charging, and sometimes purchasing a SIM card or data subscription (7, 23). For example, El País notes that many GPS devices use apps with subscriptions (€13 per month for Tractive) (24) and require internet/2G coverage to function (7). Users have reported that some applications are not intuitive (25), which can be frustrating. However, the advantage for tech-savvy owners is that these collars allow them to monitor the animal remotely (instant notifications, alerts, sound or light commands) (6, 7). Ultimately, the learning curve is greater with a smart collar, while a traditional one is practically "plug-and-play."

• Durability: Well-made traditional collars are typically very durable. A good quality collar (reinforced nylon, stainless steel) can last for years with periodic cleaning and adjustment. With no electronic parts, they only wear out from friction or exposure to water (nylon models dry quickly, leather may require conditioner). Smart collars, however, must balance durability with technology. Many incorporate water-resistant materials (e.g., IPX waterproofing) to withstand rain and mud (26). Nevertheless, the battery has a limited life: some trackers offer up to a week of continuous use (27), while others promise several weeks (for example, Invoxia claims "several weeks" per charge) (28). Generally, the more features (4G GPS, sensors), the more frequently you'll need to recharge and replace components. Additionally, if the smart device is lost or the chip is damaged, the replacement cost is often high. In contrast, replacing a broken traditional collar is cheap and simple.

• Incorporated Technology: This is where the difference is most pronounced. A traditional collar has minimal technology: sometimes a reflective strip for night visibility, a safety buckle, or a bell, but nothing electronic. A smart collar incorporates biometric sensors, GPS/GNSS, wireless connectivity (Bluetooth, Wi-Fi, 4G/LTE) (5, 9). It can even include artificial intelligence technology to process data (12). This enables advanced features (heart monitoring, sleep patterns, pedometer, health alerts) (5, 29) that no conventional collar offers. However, more technology means greater complexity: sensor calibration, risk of electronic failure, and firmware updates. A report from Alta Precisión highlights that smart collars combine "biometrics, geolocation, and wireless connectivity," allowing for proactive health and location tracking (3, 11). In contrast, a traditional collar relies solely on the owner's attention and routine veterinary care.

• Maintenance: A traditional collar requires little maintenance: you need to wash it if it gets dirty, check that it still fits properly (due to a dog's growth or a cat's shedding), and change identification tags if the information changes. On some models, replacement parts (buckles, rings) are available, but generally, it's used until it breaks. In contrast, a smart collar requires continuous attention: charging the battery (at least weekly or monthly, depending on the device) (13), updating the app and subscriptions, checking connectivity (if it has a SIM card), and cleaning the sensors or charging contacts. Some collars include accessories (removable covers for cleaning, like the Invoxia model) (30), but generally, any electronic fault can render the entire device useless. Furthermore, the owner must interpret the data provided by the technology, often in consultation with a veterinarian.

• Price: Price is another major difference. Traditional collars are inexpensive: a flat nylon or leather collar with a buckle can cost between €10 and €30 (31). Some embellishments or designer brands might increase the price, but they are generally affordable for any owner. Smart collars, on the other hand, are typically expensive: they range from €100 to €200 just for the device. In addition, many come with recurring costs. For example, the Fi Collar costs about $150 (≈ €140) plus an annual subscription of ~$99 (23). Brands like Whistle or Tractive charge service plans (for health or GPS) ranging from €40–100 per year (32, 33). Some alternatives (like TKMars) avoid a monthly subscription but require you to buy a 4G SIM card (7). Overall, using a smart collar can involve a much higher total cost than several traditional collars over time.

Which Collar is Right for You?

The choice between a traditional and a smart collar depends on your pet's type, your lifestyle, and your goals. For indoor dogs and cats that don't go out alone, a traditional collar with an ID tag (or a microchip) is usually sufficient for basic safety (2). It's ideal for those who prioritize simplicity and affordability. Conversely, for owners who walk their dog in open spaces or let their cats roam, a smart/GPS collar offers greater peace of mind: it allows you to quickly locate a lost animal (6, 7). It's also useful for people who are proactive about preventive health: they can monitor daily exercise and detect early cardiac or respiratory problems (12, 16).

For training, many professionals prefer other accessories (harnesses, martingale collars) over a flat collar, but if a traditional one is used, it must be fitted correctly (1, 20). A smart collar doesn't replace training techniques but can supplement them by recording activity or alerting to unwanted behaviors (e.g., excessive barking). For aesthetic or identity purposes, traditional collars offer a greater variety of designs and colors. Smart collars tend to have a more uniform design that is limited by their electronic components.

For small pets (miniature dog breeds or cats), current smart collars can be too heavy or bulky (21). In these cases, a lightweight traditional collar (such as thin cotton or nylon) with a quick-release system for safety is preferable, as recommended by veterinary literature (19). For large or very active dogs, a robust smart collar can withstand movement well, but many experts still opt for a harness to prevent injuries (as noted by animal welfare organizations) (17).

In summary, there is no single "best" universal collar. An owner who values technology and prevention will likely prefer a smart collar (or even multiple devices: GPS + health monitor) to track location and vital signs (6, 11). In contrast, a practical or low-budget owner might opt for a classic traditional collar, supplemented with a microchip and regular veterinary visits. The key is to analyze your specific needs: Am I looking for peace of mind when my animal is out of sight? Do I want to monitor their health every day? Or do I simply need identification and a nice look?

As veterinary experts warn, both types must be used responsibly. Smart collars are powerful, but still emerging, tools: they require supervision and professional judgment (14, 16). And traditional collars, while simple, must be chosen to fit well to prevent neck damage (17, 20). In any case, a collar (of any kind) does not replace daily love and attention: they are just another support to help us take better care of our pets.

Sources: Technical reports and specialized articles on traditional and smart collars (1, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 34). Information from veterinary experts and recent studies on safety and health monitoring (2, 11, 15, 17). Data on popular products (Fi, Tractive, Kippy, Whistle, Invoxia, etc.) obtained from recent comparisons and analyses (7, 23, 33).

(1, 20) Por qué los veterinarios recomiendan los collares para perros: Seguridad y estilo

https://wedogy.com/es/why-vets-recommend-dog-collars/

(2, 18, 19) Collares y cascabeles: ¿es conveniente su uso en gatos?

https://www.eltiempo.com/vida/mascotas/collares-y-cascabeles-es-conveniente-su-uso-en-gatos-740220

(3, 9, 11, 29) Monitor de Actividad y Salud para Mascotas (Collar Inteligente) - Alta Precisión

https://altaprecision.org/monitor-de-actividad-y-salud-para-mascotas-collar-inteligente/

(4, 8) Innovación inesperada: Collares inteligentes para las mascotas - Estilo de vida y salud

https://notipress.mx/vida/innovacion-inesperada-collares-inteligentes-mascotas-1145

(5, 12, 21, 22, 30) El collar inteligente para perros que rastrea la frecuencia respiratoria y cardiaca - Infobae

https://www.infobae.com/america/tecno/2022/01/04/el-collar-inteligente-para-perros-que-rastrea-la-frecuencia-respiratoria-y-cardiaca/

(6, 10, 15, 16) Tecnología para Mascotas: Cómo los Collares Inteligentes

https://www.clinicaveterinariaelreston.es/noticias-veterinario-valdemoro/tecnologia-para-mascotas-como-los-collares-inteligentes-y-los-monitores-de-salud-estan-revolucionando-el-cuidado-de-perros-y-gatos.html

(7, 24, 26, 27, 33) Los mejores collares con GPS para mascotas | Escaparate: compras y ofertas | EL PAÍS

https://elpais.com/escaparate/2024-10-17/collares-con-gps-para-mascotas.html

(13, 14, 23, 25, 31, 34) ¿Son útiles los collares inteligentes para perros? | DPL News

https://dplnews.com/son-utiles-los-collares-inteligentes-para-perros/

(17) Ya no es el collar: el accesorio en tendencia que eligen los dueños responsables para pasear a sus perros

https://www.canal26.com/planeta/2025/05/31/ya-no-es-el-collar-el-accesorio-en-tendencia-que-eligen-los-duenos-responsables-para-pasear-a-sus-perros/

(28) Los wearables ya no son solo para humanos: este collar puede monitorizar la frecuencia cardíaca, la respiración y el sueño de tu perro

https://www.xataka.com/otros/wearables-no-solo-para-humanos-este-collar-puede-monitorizar-frecuencia-cardiaca-respiracion-sueno-tu-perro

(32)How Much Do the WHISTLE ™ Subscription Plans Cost?

https://support.whistle.com/en_us/how-much-does-the-whistle-go-subscription-plan-cost-ry6fzwJKL